Politicians and government officials talk a lot about improving Vermont’s economy. But both politically and financially, there are limits to what the public sector can do. Now, for the second year in a row, a group of motorcycle-riding investors and entrepreneurs has set out across the state to pitch in.
It's becoming tradition in Vermont: The first week of August, riders tour through the most promising hubs in the state, stopping twice a day to get pitched by budding businesses looking for money, advice and connections. The riders — about 45 this year — are looking to invest, help out, have fun, and stay out of the rain.
Event organizer Cairn Cross says the Road Pitch, as it’s called, is a form of economic development for which the private sector is uniquely positioned.
“I personally believe that one of the problems with public sector economic development … is we tend to think of hierarchies,” Cross says. “‘How do we have a one-stop shop where everybody goes and they know exactly where to go to get all the resources?’ And the reality is, you don’t. In part because in a good entrepreneurial economy, new resources are popping up all the time.”
Cross says Road Pitch is effective because it simply gets new and experienced entrepreneurs talking.
Aside from the loud engines, helmets and leather or Gore-Tex gear, this is hardly a new concept. It’s networking. Bob Bloch, an entrepreneur, investor and business professor, says it’s what drives economies everywhere.
“Economic development doesn’t come from the government. It comes from people kicking around ideas … and supporting each other,” Bloch says. “And in communities that are more successful, it just happens more.”
And this year’s Road Pitch brought riders to some areas that could use more of it: Riders stopped first in Essex and Bennington, followed by Brattleboro and Rutland, then Randolph and Lowell. They wrapped up with stops in Morrisville and Grand Isle.
In Bennington, local organizer Brian McKenna says the Young Professionals chapter there has been striving to get the kind of attention that rolled into town recently.
“It absolutely presents opportunity,” McKenna says. “It could be investment opportunity, it could be experiential, it could be expertise. We have so much that we can learn from everybody else in the state.”
Cairn Cross says his goal in encouraging a “startup ecosystem” is just that: to create opportunities for people with resources to interact with people who need them.
“If you connect those resources together over time, things will happen,” he says.
But the long gestation period inherent in this approach, the riskiness of startups and the disruptive potential of entrepreneurialism — these can be hard sells for politicians and public officials with multiple constituencies to answer to, with taxpayers dollars to be accountable for, with results to show to for the next election.
Cross says he thinks government approaches economic development with “blunt instruments” when it looks only to tax incentives and streamlining regulation.
“If business was as easy as money and regulation, there’d be a lot more millionaires,” he says. “It’s not just money and regulation. It’s creativity, it’s leadership, it’s product design, it’s finance. It’s so many things.”
Many businesses pitching Road Pitch riders last week did ask for money. But all of them wanted advice about the rest of those things that go into business. And they got it, through informal question-and-answer sessions after each pitch.
There was a bit of bluster among some riders when they talked amongst themselves over meals or drinks in the evenings. But, the pitch atmosphere stayed wholly positive: more casual and helpful, less formal or critical than traditional pitch sessions. The goal was just to make good ideas better.
Dana Wilkinson, founder of a clothing line called The Dirty Old Biker, says it’s a supportiveness he finds pervasive in Vermont.
“Everybody seems down to earth,” Wilkinson says. “Everybody’s confident enough in what they’re doing, so they’re not selfish, they’re willing to show you what they’ve got going on.”
Cross says he doesn’t think Vermont’s startup ecosystem has reached full steam yet, but over time and with the ripple effect from events like Road Pitch, he says it will get there.