Senate Advances Bill To Grant Driver’s Licenses To Illegal Workers

Apr 5, 2013

The Vermont Senate overwhelmingly advanced a bill on Friday that would give driver’s licenses to immigrants who are in the country illegally.

The bill would create what are described as drivers’ authorization cards for people living in Vermont illegally. It would authorize the Department of Motor Vehicles to issue IDs that would look different from a regular state license.

Advocates for migrant workers who came to the United States illegally have spent two years lobbying for the bill. On Friday, senators voted 27 to 2 in favor of a version drafted by a bipartisan group of legislative leaders and the Shumlin administration.

Immigration issues are a big political issue right now. Congress hopes to create a “path to citizenship” for immigrants living in the country illegally. In Vermont, the issue has business implications, too. Vermont’s dairy industry depends on an estimated 1,500 migrant farm workers.

“They watch out for the farm, and the family watches out for them,” said Sen. Philip Baruth, D-Chittenden, who pointed to a study commissioned by the Legislature that found it’s hard for migrant workers to get around the state.

On the Senate floor, Baruth ended the one-sided debate by recalling “the long tradition in Vermont of the hired man.”

“A lot of time the hired man makes the difference between make or break for the farm,” Baruth said. “I think it’s fair to say that in the 21st century in Vermont this group of workers – migrant workers – are the new hired men.”

Migrant workers and their advocates have said the bill would allow them to come out of the shadows and move about the state more freely. Only New Mexico and Washington State have passed similar measures.

In Vermont, though, the measure has its critics. Republican Senator Norman McAllister of Franklin County is a goat farmer. He expressed some of his constituents’ concerns about issuing drivers’ IDs to migrant workers, even if the bill requires they pass a written test and drivers’ test without a translator.

“Living on the border where we do and also hearing from our farms and their nervousness as to what the liability situation could be, I can’t support this bill,” McAllister said on Friday shortly before casting his vote.

“Just the little bit that I looked into it, it didn’t seem to pass muster.”

After the vote, migrant workers wearing t-shirts and jeans thanked lawmakers in suits, including Senate President John Campbell as he walked off the Senate floor.

“Now listen, no one gets tickets,” Campbell told them, laughing. “Then we’d all be in trouble!”

Among the migrant workers in the Senate gallery was Gilberto Lopez, who arrived in Vermont from Mexico a year and a half ago to milk cows on a dairy farm in East Montpelier. Lopez said the bill would give him and his co-workers sense of dignity.

“It’s a good thing because we will have the liberty and ability to be able to do the things that we would like to do,” Lopez explained, speaking through a translator. “It’s been difficult. There have been instances when I’ve needed to go to the doctor and I wasn’t able to because I couldn’t find someone to give me a ride.”

Lopez and other migrant workers said on Friday they’re hopeful the bill will pass easily in the House.

*** The original post below was update at 5:17 p.m. ***

The Vermont Senate advanced today a bill that would grant a version of a driver’s license to people who are in the country illegally.

The bill would create what are described as drivers’ IDs for people living in Vermont illegally, including the 1,500 migrant farm workers that the dairy industry has come to rely upon.

Senators voted 27-2 for the legislation.